Mountain Equipment Co-op Questions And Answers

Looking for Answers about Footwear?

Shop(Q:13209 A:17129)
Shop General Q&A(Q:13209 A:17129)
Climbing(Q:741 A:990)
Cycling(Q:2438 A:3035)
Electronics(Q:161 A:183)
Footwear(Q:524 A:735)
Footwear General Q&A(Q:524 A:735)
Backpacking Boots(Q:33 A:38)
Gaiters(Q:23 A:28)
Insoles and Laces(Q:12 A:14)
Kids' Footwear(Q:44 A:53)
Light Trail Shoes(Q:31 A:30)
Minimalist Shoes(Q:39 A:70)
Sandals(Q:9 A:11)
Shoe and Boot Care(Q:21 A:22)
Socks(Q:44 A:53)
Traction Devices(Q:18 A:30)
Trail Running Shoes(Q:10 A:10)
Winter Boots(Q:60 A:68)
Gift Cards(Q:28 A:29)
Hiking and Camping(Q:1966 A:2568)
Kids(Q:335 A:422)
Men's Clothing(Q:738 A:920)
Packs(Q:1083 A:1373)
Running and Fitness(Q:69 A:93)
Sleeping Bags(Q:517 A:623)
Snowsports(Q:600 A:743)
Sunglasses(Q:118 A:135)
Tents(Q:537 A:673)
Top-Rated Member Picks(Q:1926 A:2756)
Travel Gear(Q:25 A:45)
Watches and Clocks(Q:187 A:245)
Watersports(Q:675 A:839)
Women's Clothing(Q:535 A:715)
Yoga(Q:1 A:1)
Shop now at MEC
or
Choose a Category
Most Recent Questions
Recent Question:
Which product do I use to protect/clean these shoes?
Recent Question:
Is the upper fully waterproof?
Recent Question:
Is the weight for both socks, or just one?
Recent Question:
Are these boots Crampon Compatable?
Questions with Most Recent Answers
Question:
I am looking for Gaiters but I can not find any that fit over my calves cause they are fat. Do you have any suggestions?
Question:
checking on size of new Patagonia ballet flat (mesh sides)for women
Question:
Is the upper fully waterproof?
Question:
five finger shoe and socks???
Question:
Is the weight for both socks, or just one?

Customer Questions & Answers for
Footwear

Customer Questions & Answers:
524 Questions
 | 
735 Answers
Footwear Page

Questions & Answers for Footwear

Question

Looking for a shoe to be used for both running and hiking

Hello

I will be traveling soon and I will be doing some hiking but I also enjoy running so I would like a shoe that allows me to do both as I do not want to bring more than one pair of shoes when me.
Should I buy a trail runner? I want something that is waterproof but breathable, flexible so I can run on trails and beaches but supportive on rough terrian.
Any suggestions?

Thanks
asked 3 years, 6 months ago
by
Tracy
on Footwear
5 answers
Answers
answer 1
ive done many gut buster trail runs..trail shoes will be fine...hiking shoes would be too heavy.
happy trails
shelagh
answered 3 years, 2 months ago
by
Anonymous
answer 2
I would suggest the Salomon XT Wings, they're a gore-tex trail runner. Not too heavy, durable, good support on the trails and I've used them on many hikes. Even found they were sturdy enough to strap crampons onto.
MEC MEMBER
MEC MEMBER
answered 3 years, 6 months ago
by
XOXOXO
 - Vancouver, BC
answer 3
If you have wide feet, Keen is the only way to go.
MEC MEMBER
MEC MEMBER
answered 3 years, 6 months ago
by
Backcountrylifer
 - Orillia ON
answer 4
You will have to compromise somewhere:

weight/support/durability/waterproof/price

Anything super lightweight usually comprimises some durability and maybe support.

Waterproof often means it will be a bit more expensive and/or less breathable.

When I travel, and space/weight is limited, I usually go with a light day-hiker with ankle support with light foam (not heavy, but supportive polyurethane) midsole. I also pack a pair of flippy-floppies for beach days.

The ankle high dayhikers are a little overkill for trail -running, but I appreciate the extra stability on the ankles.

Best of luck, have a great trip
STAFF ANSWER
STAFF ANSWER
Best Answer
Expert Answer
answered 3 years, 6 months ago
by
Jagir
 - Vancouver
answer 5
I use Merrell's, I swear by them and at them once n while, for a number of years, I think a mid shoe like the chameleon (Chameleon Ark, for women) would be best with a mid weight and it has a heavier sole for trails but not so much for running.
Where as, the Keen shellrock is a cool shoe for lite weight with some good protection
But the north face hedgehog sounds like the best of what you are looking for for the money; It really depends on how much weight and the terrain. I tend to over compensate just in case. I'd rather have too much than not enough. But the fit and comfort of this boot is very good. It is also waterproof.
MEC MEMBER
MEC MEMBER
answered 3 years, 6 months ago
by
roadwarrior
 - 108 mile ranch
Question

What footwear or footwear set-up is best for occasional river crossings while backpacking in the rockies?

asked 2 years, 10 months ago
by
Anonymous
on Footwear
5 answers
Answers
answer 1
Depends on the depth of the water . Once the water reaches the tongue of a lot of boots they leak. Look for boots with a waterproof one piece fully stitched in tongue and gortex lined between the inner and outer layer of the boot material and a welded 1"-1/14" rubber rand around the bottom where the boot material meets the sole. My personal experience is that leather boots( Gortex inner lining) provide the best support, comfort and waterproofing.Gators that slip over your boots are a definete help when crossing occasional creeks/rivers and can easily be removed ones you've crossed the water.
MEC MEMBER
MEC MEMBER
answered 2 years, 6 months ago
by
giovanni
 - Edmonton
answer 2
Any type of amphibious sandal ex. Keen Newport H2 will work well. Hang them on your pack to dry and then wear them around camp.
STAFF ANSWER
STAFF ANSWER
Best Answer
answered 2 years, 7 months ago
by
HikerDad
 - North Vancouver, BC
answer 3
Good day hikers like the Kootenay and Grinnell will be most servicable when they are carefully waterproofed with a beeswax (my preference), or mink oil product. Because of the full bellows to the tongue your feet will remain dry until water comes in over the top of the cuff.
Always ensure your boots are well broken-in, at least 40 hours of casual wear in town shopping before you take them out for a hike. My Raichle Kootenays remained dry inside from several creek crossings on rocks submerged until we stood knee-deep in a meadow swamped with water during scrambles after severe thunder storms. Wrung-out my socks and kept hiking out for 7 hours with full 80 lb pack. The Grinnells are not made in my size but they should be a first choice.
MEC MEMBER
MEC MEMBER
answered 2 years, 10 months ago
by
rockiesscrambler
 - Montreal
answer 4
Try Techphibians. Good traction when wet. Light and dry quickly.
MEC MEMBER
MEC MEMBER
answered 2 years, 10 months ago
by
Petey
 - Spruce Grove AB
answer 5
Personally I like to use a pair of fivefingers Sprint. They give a good grip and a good feel of the river bed. They dried up fairly fast too so it's a nice bonus.
MEC MEMBER
MEC MEMBER
answered 2 years, 10 months ago
by
MadMax
 - Saskatoon,Sk
Question

What type of winter boot will keep your feet warm at -4o. Preferably, a lightweight boot for walking.

asked 2 years, 6 months ago
by
Anonymous
on Footwear
5 answers
Answers
answer 1
A roomy one. Layering is the answer when it comes to feet, just like the rest of you. We've hiked in the Territories in pretty brutal temperatures, and found that what's inside the footwear is the most important thing:

-cotton to absorb water;

-thick 100% wool socks for insulation, even when damp;

-a thick wool insole, to minimize ground-based heat loss.

When it comes to the actual footwear, just make sure it's fairly high, has fur or a drawstring at the top to prevent snow intrusion, is comfortable, and has plenty of space inside. Take all of your layers with you when you go shopping!

Remember, your feet generate a lot of heat in an enclosed space, and often are the warmest part of your body. Look after moisture, and insulate to preserve heat loss, and your problems are minimal.
answered 2 years, 5 months ago
by
dabooks
 - Toronto
answer 2
I wore the "Scarpa Kailash GORE-TEX Day Hiking Boots (Men's)" on a 30km hike this weekend. My feet stayed absolutely dry (use gaitors too) and warm for the most part, but the key is to have good thick breathable socks as well. Make sure you try the boot on with some thick socks. My feet were warm almost all day except for the summit where temperatures got to -40 in the windchill. I would highly recommend these boots, but be sure to use good socks (smartwool are great). next time I will try layering my socks with a thin merino pair underneath some very thick smartwools.
answered 2 years, 5 months ago
by
stormpetrel
 - Vancouver
answer 3
Merrell Thermo Arc 8 WTPF Winter Boots (Women's)
Best Answer
answered 2 years, 5 months ago
by
Anne123
 - Winnipeg, MB
answer 4
I'd suggest that just about any shoe or boot would be fine at -4, but focus instead on socks. Something breathable that will wick away foot sweat and provide good insulation. Also focus on the other end of your body and cover your noggin with a toque to keep the heat-in. Does wonders for keeping your feet warm.
answered 2 years, 5 months ago
by
Coley
 - Toronto, ON
answer 5
Well, lightweight and -40 do not really go hand in hand unfortunately. MEC sells a selection of boots that have a manufacturer ACTIVE rating of at least -40. "Active" being the key word here. If you are just standing in the snow for 8 hours, these boots might not do the trick. The following are all rated -40 or better: Salomon Thunder (5019-576), Sorel Alpha Pac (5019-762), Merrell Isotherm (5022-753), Columbia Bugaboot (5022-537), Baffin Bison (5016-981) and Baffin Doug Stoup (5022-848). Check out the product pages for more details.
STAFF ANSWER
STAFF ANSWER
answered 2 years, 5 months ago
by
Angir
 - Service Centre
Question

Best Traction Devices?

Hi, I will be in my second trimester com this winter. I am looking for traction devices that will minimize slipping on icy and freezing rain conditions. Any recommendations is greatly appreciated.
Thanks, Catherine
asked 1 year, 6 months ago
by
Anonymous
on Footwear
5 answers
Answers
answer 1
I've been using 1/4" hex-head sheet metal screws for years...just screw them directly into the lugs on the toe and heel of your boots. I use 3 in front and 4 in back for boots and running shoes, and they can be easily replaced every year! Hope this helps.
answered 1 year, 4 months ago
by
Need2Speed
 - Edmonton
answer 2
Microspikes are great as a mini-crampon but they're not meant for sidewalks. I use them on snowy/icy bush trails and on the Ice Walks at Maligne Canyon. On an icy sidewalk, though, they'll just roll around, since the spikes need something softer to dig into.
YakTrax are fine for slippery sidewalks. Just be aware that the springs have a tendency to come unwound, and the soft rubber centres can break. Either makes them useless.
Believe it or not, the cheap 'Stabilicers' work pretty well on the city streets. Two downsides - they rust, and they can slingshot off your feet like a rubber band. Tie a shoelace across the top to stop from losing them when they peel off and wipe the water off when you're done.
 
Products from my answer
 
MEC MEMBER
MEC MEMBER
answered 1 year, 4 months ago
by
Petey
 - Parkland County, AB
answer 3
I would recommend the Kahtoola MICROspikes Traction Device but all three models MEC sells will do a good job.
STAFF ANSWER
STAFF ANSWER
Expert Answer
answered 1 year, 6 months ago
by
GRAND
 - MEC SERVICE CENTRE
answer 4
Hi Catherine; I just finished a review of the ice cleat traction device available from MEC. My review is all about me being pregnant last winter. These ice cleats are a MUST! I live in Inuvik, Northwest Territories where everything is ice, and I could RUN on the streets with the ice cleats on my boots. Now that the baby is here, I continue to wear them while carrying her so we don't fall. Definitely get them and you won't regret it! -A. Osmond (NWT).
answered 1 year, 6 months ago
by
NorthernMom
 - Inuvik, NWT
answer 5
The Yaktrax are the flatest of the traction devices offered at MEC and give reasonable traction on ice without needing to balance on the spikes in the center. They also don't destroy floors and entranceway carpets as much as others. They are very slippery on tiles, so remember to take them off before entering the grocery store.
 
Products from my answer
 
Best Answer
MEC MEMBER
MEC MEMBER
answered 1 year, 6 months ago
by
FrozenBike
Question

Need a good water proof hiking boot.

Will be doing a lot of hiking in jungle conditions so it will be warm weather.
asked 3 years, 2 months ago
by
Anonymous
on Footwear
4 answers
Answers
answer 1
The Oboz Yellowstone is hard to beat. It's lightweight, takes very little break-in and provides good support and traction. It's not too much for day hikes yet it can handle 30-40 lbs on longer trips. The uppers are mostly one piece so there aren't many seems. Well priced to for what you get.
MEC MEMBER
MEC MEMBER
answered 1 year, 10 months ago
by
JMCO
 - Bozeman, MT
answer 2
If you definitely want waterproof, have a gander at the Salomon Quest (5018-010). It has a higher ankle to help prevent filling it with water in a deceptively deep puddle, and is a little cooler and more flexible than most heavy hiking boots. The Vasque Breeze (5002-858) is another reasonably breathable option with a stiffer sole, and for something lighter weight the Salomon Fastpacker (5016-710) would work well as long as you keep your feet out of the streams.
 
Products from my answer
 
 
Vasque Breeze GORE-TEX XCR Day Hiking Boots (Men's)
4.1 out of 546 Reviews
 
 
 
 
 
STAFF ANSWER
STAFF ANSWER
answered 3 years ago
by
IanH
 - Winnipeg, MB
answer 3
There are a lot of lightweight options, but first consider if non-waterproof-way-more-breathable-than-waterproof is actually a better choice. Waterproof boots have a tendency to hold in the heat, especially in a hot climate, but sometimes they're what's needed for the job. The right choice of socks with whatever footwear you choose can make a world of difference.
Consider the Salomon Fastpacker or Vasque Breeze if you really have to go waterproof. Both are lightweight, supportive and probably have the best breathability in their category.
answered 3 years, 2 months ago
by
Seven
 - Toronto
answer 4
For wet weather hiking most people like to use a gore-tex lined boot.

However, for hot-humid hiking some people find that a full grain leather boot with a gore-tex lining does not offer enough breathability. If this is a concern to you, you may want to consider a full grain leather upper, with no gore-tex lining.
When treated and cleaned properly leather provides excellent weather protection.

As for the best boot for you, that really depends on the fit. Your best bet is to try on multiple boots until you find the one that best fits your foot.
STAFF ANSWER
STAFF ANSWER
answered 3 years, 2 months ago
by
Lesho
Question

what kind of footwear would you recommend that is warm enough for winter but not a full-sized winter boot?

I'd like something totally wearable doing errands up town, yet something that will also keep my feet warm and dry in most winter weather (I live in northern BC).
asked 2 years, 7 months ago
by
Anonymous
on Footwear
4 answers
Answers
answer 1
I've worn day hikers with goretex in the winter for years.
MEC MEMBER
MEC MEMBER
answered 11 months ago
by
Guncho
 - Oakville, Canada
answer 2
MEC Killarney 2 Day Hiking Boots

Depending on how cold it is just grab some of the woolen socks that MEC sells. Do temperatures from +40 to -40 teamperature with these boots and a good socks.
MEC MEMBER
MEC MEMBER
answered 2 years, 7 months ago
by
Quercus
 - Ottawa
answer 3
Select a winter boot that does not have a removable liner. Example would be the Columbia Bugaboot Omni-Heat 5022538. This style of boot, while not quite as warm as the removable liner type, will fit more like a hiking boot. It will be less bulky and more comfortable for walking longer distances.
STAFF ANSWER
STAFF ANSWER
answered 2 years, 7 months ago
by
HikerDad
 - North Vancouver, BC
answer 4
Sure-take a look at some of the options below.

They won't be as warm as a full winter boot, but they're a great compromise if you want something low-profile but still designed for snow.
 
Products from my answer
Keen Snowmass Mid (Women's)
 
 
 
Mawa Mid Boot
 
 
 
Deemax 2 Dry
5 out of 51 Review
 
 
 
 
 
Expert Answer
MEC MEMBER
MEC MEMBER
answered 2 years, 7 months ago
by
effie
 - squamish, bc
Question

Help with "boots"

I will be walking the,"Camino de Santaigo",in 2010,I relly need advice on hikiing "boots"!! Thanks Nancy
asked 3 years, 7 months ago
by
mosesmew
 - Yarmouth
on Footwear
3 answers
Answers
answer 1
Come in the store or call the service centre, we will assist you and help you find the best shoe for your travels.
answered 3 years, 7 months ago
by
Thomas
 - Toronto
answer 2
Best would be to go in the store and get advice from staff.
answered 3 years, 7 months ago
by
Devin
 - Calgary
answer 3
You may either go directly in a store to have direct advice; phone would be the second option (Service Center); or email info@mec.ca

If you have time to read before, you may read the learn section on MEC web site.

Best of luck!
answered 3 years, 7 months ago
by
Joe
 - Halifax
Question

Vegan Shoes

Besides the Merrel Migration and Gauly. Does MEC carry any Vegan shoes? ideally something light trail/outdoor life kind of style.
asked 3 years, 3 months ago
by
Anonymous
on Footwear
3 answers
Answers
answer 1
Try on any of the Salomon XA line or the Montrail shoe AT Plus. These are great multi-sport shoes that will bridge the trail runner/light hiker divide.
STAFF ANSWER
STAFF ANSWER
answered 3 years ago
by
Jmec
 - Service Centre
answer 2
Merrell is the only shoe company that actively promotes their vegan shoes. Most other companies make shoes without using leather, it just takes a bit more research into how and what they are made of.
STAFF ANSWER
STAFF ANSWER
answered 3 years, 1 month ago
by
IsleofJono
 - Ottawa
answer 3
Currently, the Migration and Gauley sandals are the only official vegan shoes that we carry (for men). However, we have some shoes that are made out of synthetic material like the Salomon XA PRO 3D Ultra GTX Trail running shoe. Please keep an eye out on our website for new synthetic products this spring. If you have any questions, please contact us at the service center.
 
Products from my answer
XA Pro 3D Ultra GTX Trail Running Shoes
4 out of 516 Reviews
 
 
 
 
 
STAFF ANSWER
STAFF ANSWER
answered 3 years, 2 months ago
by
Jfong
 - Vancouver, BC
Question

I have a pair of Salomon Fast Packer shoes with the speed lacing. One of the laces has broken and I am unable to find a replacement.

The Salomon speed lacing is a very thin line so normal laces won't work. The eyelets are very small. Any suggestions where replacement speed laces for Salomon shoes can be found.
asked 3 years, 1 month ago
by
Anonymous
on Footwear
3 answers
Answers
answer 1
We have the Salomon XA Spare Lace Sets in stock Product #5006826. Feel free to call the Service Centre to get a set.
STAFF ANSWER
STAFF ANSWER
answered 3 years ago
by
Jmec
 - Service Centre
answer 2
Try your local MEC.

Product number 5006-826. Search it online here or ask a staff member at your local store.
 
Products from my answer
 
STAFF ANSWER
STAFF ANSWER
answered 3 years ago
by
IanH
 - Winnipeg, MB
answer 3
MEC sells replacement Salomon speed laces. MEC product #5006826. I can not include the price unfortunately, so call your local MEC with that number and they will tell you the price and if they have them in stock. If not you can order them through our Service Centre

I am not a footwear expert and do not know if they are compatible with you particular shoes but as far as I know the same replacement lace fits all of them. Our info says they fit the XA series.
STAFF ANSWER
STAFF ANSWER
answered 3 years ago
by
LeToony Winter
 - Vancouver, BC
Question

what hiking boots are best for wide feet?

asked 3 years ago
by
Anonymous
on Footwear
3 answers
Answers
answer 1
Generally, Italian boots are the narrowest, French are next, and German are the widest. Gronells might be good.
Keens have a very wide toe box (too wide for many people), Salomon's have a wide foot and narrower heel.
Try on a number of brands in the store then walk up and down the ramps with them. Pay special attention to the downslopes and make sure your toes aren't touching the ends.
 
Products from my answer
Klondike Backpacking Boots
4.8 out of 520 Reviews
 
 
 
 
 
 
MEC MEMBER
MEC MEMBER
answered 1 year, 10 months ago
by
Petey
 - Parkland County, AB
answer 2
I have wide feet, also a straight last for my fit, so I recommend Keen boots, very comfy, but expensive. Less money in USA
MEC MEMBER
MEC MEMBER
answered 2 years, 11 months ago
by
Doon
 - Gabriola Island
answer 3
Different brands will fit differently. Your best bet is to physically try on a few different brands to see which fits you best. I have a wide foot myself and prefer Zamberlans.
answered 3 years ago
by
Anonymous
1 2 3 4 5 ... 9 next>>